America’s Test Kitchen Toaster Oven

During our search to find the best toaster oven, we looked at more than 100 models before buying the 11 that looked the best. We then compared them head-to-head. Our next step was to bake hundreds of cookies, more than 100 drumsticks, a lot of pizzas or cakes, and lots of bagels or toast. We also air-fried sweet potato fries for those places that did. After looking at all the different foods each oven could make and how easy it was to use, we’ve found the best for every kitchen, no matter what your budget or kitchen needs are.

America’s Test Kitchen Toaster Oven

1. Black + Decker TO1675B 6-Slice Countertop Convection Toaster Oven

Photo Credit-

If you’re ready for a change from your basic apartment oven, opt for the BLACK+DECKER 6-Slice Toaster Oven! Get everything you’ll ever need from your tiny kitchen appliances with this awesome piece of machinery. Now, as opposed to microwaving your cheese blintzes or re-heating your leftovers in the communal oven, you can make fresh toasties and crispy taquitos any night of the week—and who wouldn’t want that? This appliance is designed to fit conveniently on nearly any countertop, making it practical without sacrificing style. With a pre-programmed 60-minute timer, a self-clean function, and adjustable heating elements, cooking will never be this easy!

Buy on Wayfair

3. Breville BOV450XL Mini Smart Oven, Countertop Toaster Oven, Brushed Stainless Steel

Breville BOV450XL Mini Smart Oven, Countertop Toaster Oven, Brushed Stainless Steel

Imagine a toaster oven with 8 smart cooking functions. Meet the Mini Smart Oven with Element IQ. You get the speed of a countertop oven and a convection feature that works by harnessing its Ascent Steam Generator to infuse steam into the food. The Steam Roast feature actually steam cooks your food, whether it’s fresh produce for a side dish or meat for a sandwich. And with crispier, tastier results than you’ll get from toaster ovens alone, this oven is ready to become your new grill master from eggs and bacon to juicy burgers and more

Buy on Amazon

5. Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven

Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven & Pizza Maker Large 4-Slice Capacity, Stainless Steel (31401)

Even if you haven’t toasted homemade bread in years, you’ll be making toast again and again with the Hamilton Beach 2-slice countertop toaster oven. This handy appliance will toast, broil, or bake all of your favorite foods for your busy lifestyle. Plus, a compact toaster oven takes up less counter space making it great for a small kitchen or work area. Pull out crumb tray for easy cleanup.

2. BLACK+DECKER 6-Slice Digital Convection Countertop Toaster Oven, Stainless Steel, TO3280SSD

BLACK+DECKER 6-Slice Digital Convection Countertop Toaster Oven, Stainless Steel, TO3280SSD

BLACK+DECKER 6-Slice Stainless Steel Digital Convection Countertop Toaster Oven with Broiler Pan The seven specific cooking settings instantly perfect everything from 12” pizzas to reheated leftovers. The 120-minute timer has stay-on and auto-shutoff functions, and the digital controls are straightforward to use. It circulates air within the oven for quick and even baking. The toaster oven also contains a removable broiler pan and a crumb tray for easy cleanup. No need to bother about oven pans. To insert and remove food, simply use the provided baking/broiling pan. Included toasting rack

Buy on Amazon

4. Breville The Smart Toaster Oven

Photo Credit-

So for the first time ever, we’re shaking up breakfast and introducing smart oven technology to your morning routine. Our smart oven air fryer powered by our Element IQ system delivers maximum performance and versatility. Smart algorithms replicate the ideal cooking environment for air fry and 10 additional cooking techniques. Higher temperatures and super convection speed up cooking time with great crispness. With the Breville smart oven, it’s goodbye to frozen food and hello to homemade favorites cooked up in minutes.

6. COMFEE’ Toaster Oven, 4 Slice, 12L

COMFEE' Toaster Oven, 4 Slice, 12L, Multi-function Stainless Steel Finish with Timer-Toast-Bake-Broil Settings, 1100W, Perfect for Countertop (CFO-BG12(SS))

If you love the convenience of your toaster but also love the ability to fix larger meals, this countertop toaster oven is just right. It’s designed to fit easily where space is at a premium, or on any countertop. The scientific functions allow you to cook a variety of food with precision, while the timer and automatic switch off functions prevent overcooking.

Buy on Amazon

7. Oster Toaster Oven | Digital Convection Oven

Oster Toaster Oven | Digital Convection Oven, Large 6-Slice Capacity, Black/Polished Stainless

This Oster countertop oven with convection technology delivers heat rapidly and evenly for thorough cooking and superb results. a whole chicken, a casserole, or a pan of crescent rolls or chocolate-chip cookies. A tall roast requires two rack places to customize the space. The sleek, modern unit also has a stainless steel frame and a manual/digital control panel for easy use. Choose from bake, convection bake, broil, toast, pizza, defrost, and warm. One-touch controls for time and temperature. It also has a see-through door, an optional interior light, an easy-to-clean interior, and an external removable crumb tray. Includes a sturdy baking pan.

Buy on Amazon

8. Panasonic Toaster Oven FlashXpress with Double Infrared Heating

Panasonic Toaster Oven FlashXpress with Double Infrared Heating and Removable 9-Inch Inner Baking Tray, 12 x 13 x 10.25, Silver

Give your grilled cheese sandwiches, frozen pizza and toast the treatment they deserve with the Panasonic FlashXpress small toaster oven. Even though it’s small, this 2-in-1 toaster and oven has dual infrared heating which means you can pop in your food and go without relying on a preheat timer – that’s how fast it is. Four preset cooking menus with illustrated buttons automatically calculate cooking time, while a 25 minute digital timer allows you to choose when your food will be finished. The temperature settings range from 250 F to 500 F and the square shaped inner tray is perfect for a pan of freshly baked cookies, or a round pizza up to 9″ in diameter. And once your food is done, the reminder beep lets you know that it’s time to eat.

Buy on Amazon

9. Cuisinart TOB-135WN Toaster Oven

Cuisinart TOB-135WN Toaster Oven, White

The Cuisinart Deluxe is a convection toaster oven broiler that yields perfect results every time with 9 functions and 0.6 cu. ft. capacity. An electronic dial and LED buttons put precise temperature control and a whole range of cooking options at your fingertips, making the Deluxe toaster oven broiler ideal for baking cakes, roasting potatoes, crisping juicy roasts and so much more. The precise heat sensor maintains the selected temperature, and the always even shade control ensures toast will meet your family’s tastes exactly every time.

Buy on Amazon

10. Cuisinart – Air Fryer Toaster Oven

Photo Credit- BestBuy.Com

If you love fried foods but loathe the oil, this air fryer from Cuisinart is your ticket to crispy fries, chicken wings, and more. The oven compartment uses a convectional fan to circulate heat for even baking and broiling – what about making crispy toast or melting cheese for nachos? The built-in air fryer gives the option of preparing classic fried foods without the need for oil: no more deep-frying, no mess, and cleanup hassle-free.

Buy on BestBuy

11. Oster Air Fryer Countertop Toaster Oven

Oster Air Fryer Countertop Toaster Oven, French Door and Digital Controls,Stainless Steel, Extra Large, 42 L

Ready to prepare an entire meal at once? This extra-large toaster oven easily fits up to a 15″ x 12″ baking pan, a full family size chicken, or 2 extra-large pizzas. With preset cooking functions including Air Fry, Slow Cook, Bake, Toast and Broil, Dehydrate, and Pizza you can cook an entire meal anytime. Quickly preheat your oven in less than 3 minutes with the faster preheat option and enjoy healthy fried foods without oil. This kitchen appliance is designed to make it easy and convenient to cook whole meal at once!

Buy on Amazon

12. BLACK+DECKER 02648008504 Countertop Convection Toaster Oven

BLACK+DECKER 02648008504 Countertop Convection Toaster Oven, Silver, CTO6335S

Introducing a new take on an old favorite. The BLACK+DECKER 6-Slice Stainless Steel Convection Countertop Toaster Oven with Broiler Pan has one-touch functions for a whole range of foods: bagels, pizza, frozen snacks, potatoes, and cookies. Convection technology circulates air within the oven for fast and even results while baking. Plus, the toaster oven includes a broiler pan and an external crumb tray that slides in and out, making cleanup a breeze. If you care about good food and want to be sure it comes out just right every time, this is the toaster oven for you!

Buy on Amazon

13. NUWAVE Bravo Air Fryer Toaster Smart Oven

Oster Air Fryer Countertop Toaster Oven, French Door and Digital Controls,Stainless Steel, Extra Large, 42 L

Invented right here in the USA and built tough to last a lifetime, the NuWave Bravo countertop oven gives you oven-quality results without the high energy costs. It’s your favorite recipes now quicker, healthier, and more convenient than ever with 12 Presets & an Integrated Temperature Probe. The Glass Lid allows for easy viewing of food as it cooks. This extremely efficient countertop cooker is safer than most other cooking methods and it takes up much less space than a traditional oven. You can even cook at night with its blue backlit LCD touchscreen!

14. VAL CUCINE 26.3 QT/25 L Extra-Large Smart Air Fryer Toaster Oven

Oster Air Fryer Countertop Toaster Oven, French Door and Digital Controls,Stainless Steel, Extra Large, 42 L

The val cucine 26.3 Qt/25 L Extra-Large Smart Air Fryer Toaster Oven is equipped with a high performance digital display, five precise cooking levels and the latest technology in air circulation to prepare perfect meals every time. It has four preprogrammed menorycooking menu options: fry, bake, roasted and rotisserie, and can also be used as a grill or a convection oven with adjustable temperature and cooking time. A touch of fantasy combined with a passion for food and design makes it essential to create your delicious home experience.


A toaster oven can add a lot of cooking power to a dorm room or a small kitchen in a city. It doesn’t take up much space. Even if you already have a full-sized oven in your kitchen, these countertop models can still be good to have. Conventional ovens take a long time to heat up and use a lot of energy. With so many different types of toasters ovens on the market, it might seem like they’re all the same. But when you start to look at the specifics, you’ll find that the quality varies a lot. There are a lot of different types of furniture out there, so we hope that our expert review has helped you figure out which one is best for your space, tastes, and budget.

Leave a Comment